Tax Tips & Traps – Winter 2015Brian Jang ON October 29, 2015
TaxTipsTraps_Winter_2015 PDF . 2.4MB
IN THIS EDITION
Quick points to consider
REQUEST FOR A CHANGE TO THE FISCAL PERIOD
Simplify your Reporting
PROVIDING INFORMATION TO CRA
But I Don’t Want To!
BLOGGER’S BUSINESS LOSSES
Personal or Commercial Venture?
CRA COLLECTIONS Watch Out!
GIFT CARDS FOR PROMOTIONAL PURPOSES
Are they Fully Deductible?
Loss of EI Benefits for Maternity Leave
BOOKS AND RECORDS RETENTION
How Long Should I Keep my Documents?
TFSA CONTRIBUTION ROOM Cautions and Possibilities
TAX TICKLERS: some quick points to consider
- Being audited by CRA does not mean that an individual will not be audited in the next year. Where CRA obtains additional tax as a result of an audit, the likelihood of a follow-up audit is generally increased.
- Certain tax slips (e.g. T4, T4A, T5 etc.) must now be submitted to the CRA electronically if more than 50 are to be sent. Penalties range from $250 to $2,500.
- A charity’s ability to issue donation receipts can be put in jeopardy if it doesn’t remove partisan political comments posted by third parties on its social media feeds (e.g. Facebook pages).
Contact us if you have questions or wish to discuss!
REQUEST FOR A CHANGE TO THE FISCAL PERIOD: Simplify your Reporting
In an October 16, 2014 Technical Interpretation, CRA noted that they may accept a change to a taxpayer’s fiscal period. However, the request to change should only be approved when the request is prompted solely on sound business reasons other than to obtain a tax benefit. Changes for the personal convenience of the taxpayer and to defer taxes would not be permitted.
CRA provided a non-exhaustive list of reasons that could constitute a sound business reason:
- a corporation changes its fiscal period to end on the same date as its parent or associated company;
- a corporation changes its fiscal period to end when its inventory is at a seasonally low level;
- a corporation changes its fiscal period to ease financial reporting.
Action Item: If it makes sense, due to a sound business reason, to change the fiscal period, contact us to consider making an application.
PROVIDING INFORMATION TO CRA: But I Don’t Want To!
In a May 14, 2015 Federal Court of Canada case, the taxpayer was found to be in contempt of Court for not providing CRA with documents as ordered. This case is an example of what may occur when documents are not provided, as requested, to CRA. The actions proceeded as follows:
- March 3, 2013 – CRA made seven requests of documents to be provided in 30 days.
- July 12, 2013 – CRA obtained a Court Order requesting the documents.
- February 4, 2014 – The taxpayer was found in contempt of Court for not providing the documents and was fined $1,500, assessed court costs of $2,500, and again required to provide the documents.
- May 14, 2015 – The Court found the taxpayer in contempt again for continuing to not provide the required information. The taxpayer was required to pay an additional fine of $2,000, and $3,000 in court costs.
Action Item: Contact us as soon as CRA contacts you or requests information. Delaying action could be very costly.
BLOGGER’S BUSINESS LOSSES: Personal or Commercial Venture?
In a June 19, 2015 Tax Court of Canada case, at issue was whether a former radio personality and sports journalist could claim business losses incurred for the 2011 and 2012 years to offset his other income. During these years, the taxpayer started and operated a sports blog with the intention of selling advertising. At question was whether he was operating a business or simply financing a hobby.
The Court found that the taxpayer was carrying on a business and, therefore, was entitled to deduct losses in 2011 and 2012. The Court examined the taxpayer’s “business-like” behaviour including:
• The taxpayer’s training – The taxpayer had over 20 years’ experience in sports reporting. He was not a sports fan believing he could be a journalist, rather, a professional sportswriter believing he could be a businessman.
• The taxpayer’s intended course of action – While the taxpayer did not write a formal business plan or make financial projections, he did have a simple plan: write a quality blog and the sponsors will come. Although the taxpayer’s course of action may have displayed poor business judgement, it was not lacking such commercial substance to conclude the venture was personal.
• The capability of the venture to show a profit – The taxpayer was not able to provide any solid data on projections, comparisons or readership numbers, rather he just provided a suggestion that readership was increasing. While not helpful, this was not fatal to his case.
• The profit and loss experience in the past years – This was not a significant issue as there were no past years to address.
The Court also noted that even if there is a personal pursuit (the taxpayer was a sports journalist and a sports fan), if the operations are carried out in a sufficiently commercial manner, the venture would still be considered a source of income (in other words, a business).
Action Item: When starting a business, ensure to fully document and execute “business-like” behavior to support the commercial substance of the venture.
CRA COLLECTIONS: Watch Out!
The CRA has special abilities to collect debts from taxpayers where amounts are left outstanding for too long. Some of the issues to be considered when dealing with CRA collections include:
- CRA has the ability to garnish one’s bank account or wages.
- CRA can reduce government payments, such as CPP, when amounts are outstanding.
- If a taxpayer is disputing an assessment or amount outstanding, payment of the assessed amount will not generally impact the success, or failure, of their objection.
- It may be beneficial to pay the outstanding amount even if an assessment will be disputed. If the objection is successful, the CRA will pay taxable interest of 3% to individuals (1% to corporations). If unsuccessful, the taxpayer will avoid non-deductible interest CRA charges of 5%. These rates are re-evaluated quarterly.
- In some cases, CRA is restricted in their ability to collect where a taxpayer has objected or appealed. However, the Tax Act does not limit collections for debts such as source deductions, and GST/HST.
- Collection restrictions may be lifted where a delay puts collection at risk.
- Giving assets to non-arm’s length parties (such as a spouse or child) in an attempt to prevent CRA from collecting, can cause the recipient to also be liable for a portion of the tax debt.
Action Item: Consider paying an amount in dispute with CRA to avoid accruing non-deductible interest should you lose your Objection or Appeal.
GIFT CARDS FOR PROMOTIONAL PURPOSES: Are they Fully Deductible?
In a November 14, 2014 French Technical Interpretation, CRA was asked whether gift cards given away for promotional purposes, such as those provided to customers or clients, would be classified as a “meal and entertainment” expense which would reduce the deduction for tax purposes by 50%.
CRA indicated that their general presumption is that the 50% reduction would apply where the main product of the issuer of the gift card is food or beverages. They noted, however, that this presumption could be rebutted with appropriate supporting documentation.
Action Item: Consider giving gift cards to customers for stores and companies that do not primarily provide food, beverages or entertainment.
INSURABLE EMPLOYMENT: Loss of EI Benefits for Maternity Leave
In a January 23, 2015 Tax Court of Canada case, the worker (spouse of the sole shareholder) was determined by a CPP/EI Rulings Officer to not be engaged in insurable employment with the Company because she and the Company were not dealing with each other at arm’s length.
This would mean that EI contributions would not have to be remitted, however, EI benefit claims could not be received either.
A spouse, or family member of the shareholder may earn insurable amounts only if their employment contract is substantially similar to one that would be accepted by an arm’s length party.
The Court considered various factors to determine that the contract was not substantially similar to one that would be accepted by an arm’s length party, including:
- the worker was not paid on a regular basis and was paid below market rate for her services;
- the worker did not track her hours, nor did she receive overtime payments;
- the financial performance of the Company indicates that it did not have the finances to support the worker’s position – this led to the inference that the position was introduced to provide employment to the worker; and,
- the payer was unable to hire a replacement when the worker went on maternity leave – another indication no one other than the spouse of the shareholder would be willing to accept similar terms of employment.
Action Item: If the business owner is employing family members, contact us to determine if their earnings are insurable.
BOOKS AND RECORDS RETENTION: How Long Should I Keep my Documents?
In a May 11, 2015 Technical Interpretation, CRA was asked about the required period for records retention. CRA noted the following:
- A corporation’s permanent records (including Minutes of Directors’ and Shareholders’ Meetings, share registers, the general ledger, and any contracts or agreements necessary to understand the general ledger entries) must be retained until two years after the corporation is dissolved.
- In the absence of an exception, a corporation’s non-permanent records must be retained for a period of six years after the end of the last taxation year to which they relate. For example, invoices for the purchases of capital assets must generally be kept for 6 years after they are disposed, not just 6 years after purchase. All non-permanent corporate records on hand at the date of dissolution must be retained for two years after the date of dissolution.
- Permanent records of an unincorporated business must be retained for six years after the end of the taxation year in which the business ceased, while other records must be retained for six years after the end of the last taxation year to which they relate.
Action Item: Review internal controls to ensure the permanent and non-permanent records (such as invoices for the purchase of capital assets) are retained for the appropriate length of time.
CANADA U.S. BORDER INFORMATION EXCHANGE
As of July 1, 2014 Canada and U.S. Immigration began to share their Canada-U.S. entry and exit data with each other. However, the U.S. may not be aware of when a Canadian departs from the U.S. in certain cases. This may result in incorrect data being provided to Canada about the number of days that a Canadian resident spends in the U.S..
Action Item: This possibly incorrect information, coupled with increased information exchange, makes it particularly important for Canadians to carefully track their entries and exits.
CRA USING SOCIAL MEDIA?
It is possible for the CRA, and other similar bodies, to use social media to identify taxpayers for audits, or even to use as evidence against the taxpayer in the course of a reassessment. For example, posts regarding the creation of large balances in a TFSA on Linked-In, Twitter, or Facebook may result in an audit of the individual’s TFSA. If the CRA believes that an individual is carrying on an equity trading business within the TFSA account, they may challenge the tax-free status of the account.
It is also important to note that not only will a direct view of the post by CRA possibly result in an audit, but also, an anonymous tip could cause the same result. Every post puts the user at the mercy of the individuals in their network, and far beyond if it is shared.
Action Item: Caution should be taken when posting tax or other related information on social media.
TFSA CONTRIBUTION ROOM: Cautions and Possibilities
Although withdrawals from a TFSA are added to the available contribution room, the limit is increased only at the start of the following calendar year. As such, a series of contributions and withdrawals within a calendar year can expose the individual to significant costs in the form of a 1% per month tax on excess contributions.
Also note that if an adult child, or other relative, has TFSA contribution room available, a gift or loan may be made to that person so that they may invest in their TFSA account. This would essentially convert taxable investment income of the wealthier person into tax-free income of the other.
TFSA contribution limits for specific individuals can be found by logging onto “My Account” at www.cra-arc.gc.ca. Caution, however, must be taken when relying on these balances as the CRA may not have the most current information.
Action Item: Before contributing to a TFSA, individuals should consider their contribution room so as to avoid tax on excess contributions.
The preceding information is for educational purposes only. As it is impossible to include all situations, circumstances and exceptions in a newsletter such as this, a further review should be done by a qualified professional. Although every reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this newsletter, no individual or organization involved in either the preparation or distribution of this letter accepts any contractual, tortious, or any other form of liability for its contents.For any questions… give me a call.
- Registering for the GST Retroactively
- Which Canadian Business Structure is Right for You?
- The Gig Economy in 2020: Tips for Saving Taxes
- How the Government is Helping Seniors During the COVID-19 Pandemic
- The True Costs of Everyday Expenses